CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR (Continued): There are two subdivisions of this sort of fear: the first is in regard to the present moment and the future, and the second is in regard to the past. In regard to the present it implies that you should fear and worry about what you are doing or are about to, lest there be or come to be something in it that is not fitting for G-d's honor, as we have explained above. In the regard to the past, you should constantly think about what you have already done, and fear and worry that some transgression might have unknowingly come your way. This was the case with Baba ben Buttah who used to offer a suspected-guilt-offering every day (K'ritut 25a), and with Job, who arose early in the morning after his sons' parties, and "offered burnt offerings according to the number of them, for Job said, 'It may be that my sons have sinned'..." (Job 1:5). Our sages pointed out (Horayot 12a) that in regard to the anointing oil with which Moses anointed Aaron as High Priest it is said, "it shall not anoint human flesh" (Exodus 30:32). Yet it was explicitly commanded that Aaron be anointed with it! Moses and Aaron were afraid they had misappropriated its use in some way, and had gone against a commandment. Moses was worried and said, "Maybe I have misappropriated the anointing oil!" But a voice was heard to say, "'As the good oil that is upon the head descends upon the beard, the beard of Aaron... as the dew of Hermon' (Psalms 133:2–3) -- just as the dew of Hermon is not misappropriated, the anointing oil on Aaron's beard is not misappropriated." But Aaron was still worried. Maybe Moses had not misappropriated, but he had, he wondered? But a voice was heard to say, "'How good and how pleasant it is when brothers sit together in unity'" (Psalms 133:1) -- just as Moses had not misappropriated, you have not misappropriated', it explained." Here you see the ways of the pious. They would even worry about some small measure of impurity creeping (G-d forbid) into the mitzvot they have done. After Abraham finished coming to the rescue of his nephew who had been abducted, he was worried and wondered if perhaps all of his actions had not been completely meritorious. Our sages made reference to this in their explanation of the verse, "Do not be afraid, Abraham" (Genesis 15:1), when they said in the name of Rabbi Levi, "Because Abraham was afraid that somehow, between all of the soldiers that he had killed, there might have been a righteous or G-d-fearing man, he was told, 'Do not be afraid, Abraham (-- there was not)'" (Bereshit Rabbah 44:4). It is said in Tanna D'Bei Eliyahu (chapter 25), "'Do not be afraid', as in, 'Do not be afraid, Abraham' is only said to one who is truly G-d-fearing." This is the kind of fear about which it is said "The Holy One blessed be He only has His treasure-chest of G-d-fearers" (Berachot 33b). Only Moses found it easy to obtain this sort of fear, thanks to his great clinging to G-d, while others were certainly greatly deterred by their corporeality. However, every pious person should try to attain to this as much as possible, as it is said, "His holy ones will fear G-d" (Psalms 34:10). CHAPTER TWENTY-FIVE: The only way to acquire this sort of fear is to contemplate two truisms: that G-d's Presence is found everywhere, and that He involves Himself in everything, great and small. Nothing is hidden from Him, either because of its vastness or its insignificance. Whether a thing is great or small, scant or imposing, He constantly sees and understands it. This is what the Torah refers to when it says, "The whole world is full of His Glory" (Isaiah 6:3); "Do I not fill heaven and earth?" (Jeremiah 23:24); "Who is like G-d our G-d, who dwells on high-- who lowers Himself to look upon the heavens and the earth?" (Psalms 113:5-6); and, "Though G-d is high up, He nonetheless notices the lowly..."(Psalms 138:6). When it will become clear to you that wherever you are, you are standing before the Divine Presence, you will arrive at the fear and dread of stumbling in actions that would not be fitting before G-d's profound Glory. This is what is indicated by the teaching, "Know what is above you-- a seeing eye, a hearing ear-- and that all of your actions are recorded in a book" (Pirke Avot 2:1). Since the Holy One (blessed be He) involves Himself in everything, and He sees and hears everything, you can be sure of the fact that all actions make an impression and are recorded in a book for merit or blame. But this only touches you personally if you constantly reflect upon and observe it. This sort of thing is beyond our ordinary perceptions, and the mind can only grasp it after much meditation and contemplation. And even after it will have made an impression, that impression will be easily lost if you do not constantly work at it. Just as a lot of contemplation is the only way to attain constant fear of Heaven, diversion of attention (either purposeful, or because of external interference) or lack of concentration is the way to lose it. And all diversion of attention is a taking away from the state of constant fear of Heaven. This is why the Holy One (blessed be He) commanded all kings of Israel to have the Torah "with him and to read it all the days of his life so that he might learn to fear G-d his G-d" (Deuteronomy 17:19) This comes to teach that fear of Heaven can only be learned with constant study. A careful analysis of the verse further indicates that it reads, "so that he might learn to fear G-d his G-d" rather than, "so that he might fear G-d his G-d." That is so because the fear of heaven does not come naturally. In fact, it is very unnatural to us, because of the limited, this-worldly nature of our senses. It only comes to us with study. And the only kind of study that brings it to us is constant diligence in Torah and its path, which involves reflecting and meditating upon this at all times-- when you are relaxing, travelling, lying down, and awakening. The veracity of this-- that the Divine Presence is ever-present, and that we stand before G-d each and every moment-- must be set in your mind. Only then can you truly fear and revere G-d. King David would pray for this and say, "Teach me Your ways, G-d, so that I may walk in Your truth; unite my heart so that I might fear Your Name" (Psalms 86:11). © 1996 Rabbi Yaakov Feldman
Thursday, September 20, 2007
Messilas Yesharim (Thurs., Sept. 20th)
Posted by Rabbi Yaakov Feldman at Thursday, September 20, 2007
Wednesday, September 19, 2007
Messilas Yesharim (Wed., Sept. 19th)
CHAPTER TWENTY-THREE (Continued): Another deterrent to humility is the association with flatterers who steal your heart away with their praise. They will praise and exalt you for their own ulterior motives by expanding upon the good points you possess to the hilt, and then praise you unjustifiably in addition. And sometimes the very thing you are being praised for is what you should not be praised for. The point of the matter is that human intelligence is actually quite weak, and human nature is gullible and easily swayed-- especially when it comes to something it just naturally leans towards. When you hear those sorts of things being said about you by someone you trust, a certain poison enters into you, you fall into the trap of arrogance and are captured. We find this to be the case with Yo'ash who was virtuous as long as he studied with his master, Y'hoyadah the Cohen, but who, after Y'hoyadah's death, listened to and took in what his servants said when they flattered and lauded him, and likened him to a G-d (2 Kings 12:3). This sort of thing is clear in the case of most kings, Lords and people of stature. No matter where they stand spiritually, they still stumble and suffer ruination as a result of the flattery of the people who surround them. Therefore, the intelligent person will be more careful and scrutinizing of the person he would want to befriend, be counseled by, or oversee his household than he would of what he eats or drinks. Food or drink could only harm his body, but bad friends and associates could ruin his soul, his possessions and his honor. King David said, "The one who goes along the honest way will serve me. A deceiver will not dwell in the midst of my house" (Psalms 101:6–7). There is nothing better for you than to make friends with honest people who will open your eyes to matters you are blind to, and reproach you lovingly. They will save you from all evil. For what you cannot see when you overlook faults as we all do, they can, and they will warn you about it so that you will be protected. Regarding this it is said, "Salvation comes about through a lot of counsel" (Proverbs 24:6). CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR: You will notice that this trait [i.e., fear of sin] is placed after all of the exalted traits we have discussed to this juncture. That should be enough to point out to us its importance. It is only fitting that it would be a very special and essential matter which is difficult to obtain, as would be expected of a trait that could only be reached by one who has obtained those already discussed to this point. We must however start off by saying that there are two sorts of fear that are actually three, the first of which is very easy to obtain-- there is nothing easier than it-- and the second of which is the hardest. When you have perfected it, you have perfected a lot. The first category is fear of punishment. The second is fear of, or reverence for G-d's Grandeur, of which fear of sin is the subcategory. We will now explain their essences and how they differ. Fear of punishment is when you are literally afraid of transgressing the dictates of G-d because of the punishments (either corporeal or capital) that are due transgressors. This is certainly very easy to come to because everybody has an instinct for self-preservation and is concerned for his well-being, and there is nothing that is more likely to keep you away from doing something harmful to yourself than fear of its consequences. But this sort of fear is only fitting for illiterates and for simple-minded women-- not for sages and intellectuals. The second category is fear of, or reverence for G-d's Grandeur. This holds sway when you keep away from transgressions and do not commit them, for the sake of G-d's great Glory. After all, how can it ever occur to the lowly and despicable heart that is man's to do something that runs counter to G-d's will? This sort of fear (or reverence) is not so easy to obtain. It only comes about through the knowledge and understanding that is brought on by the contemplation of the Grandeur of G-d and the markedly lower state of mankind. These are the sorts of realizations that come to those who understand and delve into these matters, and are like the reverence we noted earlier on in the second section of one of the subcategories of piety. A person in this category would be abashed and would tremble when standing before, praying to and serving his Maker. This is the most praiseworthy of fears for which the pious of the world are most exalted. It is what Moses was referring to when he said, "... to fear this glorious and fearful name, G-d your G-d" (Deuteronomy 28:58). This, the fear we are explaining now, that is, the fear of sin, is both a subcategory of fear of, or reverence for G-d's Grandeur and a category in its own right. It essentially involves your constantly fearing and worrying that your actions might contain a trace of transgression, or that there might be some small or even large thing therein that is not fitting for the Glory and Grandeur of G-d. You can see the obvious relationship between this sort of fear and the aforementioned fear of, or reverence for G-d's Grandeur. Their common denominator is that you do nothing against G-d's lofty Honor. But what makes them different enough that they are two separate sorts and require two different names is the fact that the fear of, or reverence for G-d's Grandeur pertains only when you are either doing something, or are in the midst of serving G-d, or you are at the crossroads of a possible transgression. Because when you are worshipping or serving and a transgression is set before you and you recognize it as such, you should be abashed and ashamed, should shake and shiver for the loftiness of G-d's honor, and not do it so as not to (G-d forbid) rebel before G-d. But fear of sin should be a constant thing. You should always be afraid of stumbling and doing something or some half of something that is against G-d's honor. That is why this trait is called "fear of sin", because its essence is the fear that sin might enter into or mix in with your actions due to some negligence, weakness, or one or another unconscious reason. It is said regarding this, "The man who is constantly afraid is fortunate"(Proverbs 28:14), which our sages explained refers "to matters of Torah" (Berachot 60a). Even at those times when you do not see the stumbling-block before your eyes you should be anxious that it might be hidden and you are not being careful enough. Regarding such a fear our master Moses said, "G-d has come to test you so that His fear may be on your faces, and you will not sin" (Exodus 20:17). This is the sort of fear a person should have. He should be agitated at all times and never allow this fear to leave him, for he will thus by never come to transgress. And should he transgress, it will be considered to have been done under duress. Isaiah said in his prophecy, "but I will look to this man-- to him that is poor, broken of spirit, and trembles at my word" (Isaiah 66:2). King David praised this trait when he said, "Princes pursued me unjustifiably, but my heart feared only Your word" (Psalms 119:161). We find that the great and awesome angels constantly shiver and tremble for the Majesty of G-d. Our sages said parabolically about this, "From where does the River of Fire emit? From the perspiration of the Chayot Angels" (Chagiga 13b), all of which comes about from the great terror the angels experience at all times in regard to G-d's Grandeur. They fear that they might overlook some small aspect of the honor and holiness due Him. Whenever or wherever the Divine Presence is revealed there is shaking, shivering and trembling. The Torah refers to this when it says, "The earth shook and the heavens dropped at the presence of G-d" (Psalms 68:9); and "Would that you would tear the heavens and come down, that the mountains would melt at your Presence" (Isaiah 63:19). This goes even more so for humans. It is only right that we should tremble and shiver in the knowledge that we are constantly standing in the Presence of G-d, and that it is so easy for us to do something that is not fitting before G-d's exaltedness. This is what Eliphaz was referring to when he said to Job, "What is man that he should be worthy, that one born of a woman should be righteous? Behold he has no faith in His holy ones, and in his sight, the heavens are not worthy" (Job 15:14–15); as well as, "Behold, he does not have faith in His servants, and he charges His angels with foolishness. How much more those who live in houses of clay" (Job 4:18–19). Therefore every person must certainly tremble and shiver at all times. Elihu then said, "My heart trembles and is moved out of its place at this as well; listen closely to the noise of His voice" (Job 37:1–2). This is the sort of fear that the truly pious should have on their faces at all times. © 1996 Rabbi Yaakov Feldman
Posted by Rabbi Yaakov Feldman at Wednesday, September 19, 2007
Tuesday, September 18, 2007
"Eight Chapters" (Chapter Eight, Part 6)
“Spiritual Excellence” with Rabbi Yaakov Feldman
Our Current Text: Moshe Maimonides's (Rambam's) “Eight Chapters”
-- Rabbi Feldman's ongoing series for Torah.org
**********************************************************
"Eight Chapters"
Chapter Eight (Part 6)
Some believe that G-d compels each and every step we take; that “our rising up, our sitting down, and all our movements are dependent on G-d’s will”, as Rambam puts it. They honestly think that nothing we do is in our own hands -- that G-d alone decides what’s to be done, when, and how -- and that at best we can come along for the ride happily or sadly, but come along we must.
But Rambam adamantly pooh-poohs that. After all, it suggests that we’re incapable of independent action and that we haven’t any free will which allows us to claim any number of inanities if we sin. That’s unacceptable to Rambam, since we’re specifically charged to do this or avoid that, and we’re to answer for all of our actions.
(It’s important to appreciate that this controversy lies at the heart of many disparities between the so-called “rationalists” and “mystics”. Rationalists like Rambam -- who was not always the stark rationalist he’s taken to be by the way, in that he certainly had his mystical side -- contend that G-d allows us complete independence. Mystics such as the Baal Shem Tov and others assert that everything, ourselves included, is utterly dependent upon G-d moment by moment, since He’s omnipotent and can never be disobeyed in fact. But understand that this touches upon a world of arguments that are far beyond our scope here.)
Rambam does admit though that it can be said that G-d controls our moves in a certain, broad sense. For just as “if you were to throw a stone in the air and it came back down, it would be correct to say it did that because G-d wanted it to” since He set the laws of gravity in place, it’s nonetheless “not true to say that G-d wants” that particular stone “to fall at that very moment”. And so while I could certainly claim that G-d “wanted” me to touch a particular person’s credit card if I lowered my hand down to it in order to steal it, I certainly couldn’t claim that He wanted me to take it. That decision was my own.
Those who disagree -- who “contend that G-d’s will manifests itself in everything, each and every moment” -- are wrong, Rambam asserts. He contends that “G-d had already expressed His will (about the general pattern of events) in the course of the six days of creation, and that things act in accordance with their nature from then on”. In other words, He doesn’t dictate nature moment by moment. Our sages said about it that, “the world always pursues its usual course“(Avodah Zara 54B), and they “always avoided ascribing G-d’s will to particular things at particular moments” Rambam adds.
The bottom line as far as Rambam is concerned is that “just as G-d designated man to stand vertically, be broad-chested, and have fingers” and thus granted him the tools with which to act, “so too did He designate him to move about or stay in place at will, and to act freely, without anything compelling him to or preventing him from doing so”.
So, there are a couple of lessons we’re to take from this. First, since we’re free to make our own moral decisions, we need to know the difference between right and wrong as the Torah lays it out, and to bear the consequences of our deeds. And second, that we’re to “accustom ourselves to do good things and achieve character virtues, and avoid doing bad things” as well as to “undo any flaws we might already have” rather than claim that we can’t change. Because, Rambam adds, “any circumstance can be turned round from good to bad or from bad to good-- the decision is in your hands alone”.
(c) 2007 Rabbi Yaakov Feldman and Project Genesis
(Feel free to contact me at feldman@torah.org )
********************************
AT LONG LAST! Rabbi Feldman's translation of "The Gates of Repentance" has been reissued at *at a discount*!
You can order it right now from here
Rabbi Yaakov Feldman has also translated and commented upon "The Path of the Just", and "The Duties of the Heart" (Jason Aronson Publishers). His new work on Maimonides' "The Eight Chapters" will soon be available.
Rabbi Feldman also offers two free e-mail classes on www.torah.org entitled
"Spiritual Excellence" and "Ramchal"
Posted by Rabbi Yaakov Feldman at Tuesday, September 18, 2007
